Skip to content

Coinbase Challenges SEC on Crypto Rulemaking in Court

Coinbase challenges the SEC in court to initiate rulemaking for the crypto industry, arguing the agency's refusal violates the Administrative Procedures Act.

Coinbase is intensifying its legal battle against the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) by seeking judicial intervention to compel the agency to initiate rulemaking for the cryptocurrency industry. The move comes after the SEC denied Coinbase's request for clear regulatory guidelines, a decision Coinbase argues violates the Administrative Procedures Act (APA).

Key Arguments from Coinbase:

  • Violation of APA: Coinbase asserts that the SEC's refusal to engage in rulemaking, as requested in a July 2022 petition, lacks a reasoned justification, violating the APA. The exchange criticizes SEC Chair Gary Gensler's stance that existing securities laws are adequate for crypto as insufficient and unexplained.
  • Demand for Clarity: The legal challenge emphasizes the SEC's aggressive enforcement actions against crypto companies for securities laws violations, despite the agency's failure to clarify how these laws apply to cryptocurrencies.
  • Call for Rulemaking: Coinbase is urging the Third Circuit Appeals Court to direct the SEC to commence the rulemaking process, providing a platform for public understanding and debate over the regulatory approach to digital assets.

Coinbase’s Critique of SEC’s Stance:

  • Inconsistent Positions: The brief highlights the SEC's purported shift from acknowledging limited authority over crypto with existing legal ambiguities to later asserting comprehensive regulatory control.
  • Congressional Approval: Coinbase argues that any significant change in the SEC's regulatory approach requires explicit authorization from Congress, challenging the agency's unilateral expansion of its jurisdiction over crypto markets.

Broader Implications:

  • Legal Precedent: This case could set a precedent for how regulatory agencies are required to engage with emerging technologies and markets, particularly regarding the necessity for clear rulemaking processes.
  • Industry-Wide Impact: A court mandate for the SEC to undertake rulemaking could lead to more transparent and predictable regulatory frameworks for the cryptocurrency industry, potentially influencing future enforcement actions and compliance requirements.

This appeal against the SEC's rulemaking denial is distinct from the SEC's June 2023 lawsuit against Coinbase, which accuses the platform of operating as an unlicensed exchange and offering unregistered securities. Coinbase's arguments in both cases revolve around the claim that the SEC lacks authority over crypto exchanges without explicit legislative endorsement.

As Coinbase and the SEC continue to confront each other in court, the outcomes of these legal battles could have significant ramifications for the regulation and operation of the cryptocurrency industry in the United States.